Why a Photo of a Diverse Staff Made These White Men Angry
Three black women engaged in a serious discussion at an office meeting | Photo by Christina Morillo via Pexels

Why a Photo of a Diverse Staff Made These White Men Angry

When Black people enter spaces where they've long been excluded, some critics call it an attack on merit. The reactions reveals more than the inclusion does.

Is diversity the Achilles’ heel of white men? Just as the Greek warrior seemed to embody unwavering strength until Apollo struck his heel, white men, a group with vast social, economic, and political power, seem easily triggered by the presence of Black people. How else could we explain why Elon Musk, one of the wealthiest white men in the world, acted as if a simple photo shared by Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger wounded him? The image features key members of her cabinet, including three Black women, three Black men, and a white woman.

“I’m proud to have the most talented, hardest-working cabinet in Virginia’s history. They are also the most diverse cabinet,” Governor Abigail Spanberger shared as a caption to the photo. In response, Elon Musk, the Chief Technology Officer of X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, responded by saying, “You are utterly racist and sexist regarding White men. Shame on you!” Calling a white woman “racist” for hiring Black people exposes a shallow understanding of the term and the defensive nature of some white men when confronted with diversity.They portray the inclusion of Black people as a form of racism against them.

Critics of diversity fail to consider the context surrounding discussions about race and racism.America has never taken substantive steps to eradicate racial inequalities produced through discriminatory laws and policies targeting Black people. As a result, Black people have less wealth and are less likely to be hired, paid the same, or offered leadership roles at the same rate as their white counterparts. One study found white applicants were 50% more likely to receive a callback than applicants with African American names, with identical qualifications. Seeing no white man featured in a photo of Virginia cabinet members should not provoke outrage, sweaty palms, or reddened cheeks.

If White men are oppressed, then why is it that Spanberger is the first woman to ever serve as governor in that region? Virginia, founded as a British colony in 1607 and becoming a state in 1788, had ample time for residents to vote for a woman, Black people, and other marginalized groups, but didn’t. During chattel slavery, Black people could not vote there, and state poll taxes and literacy tests enforced during Jim Crow disenfranchised Black voters, contributing to disparities in health, education, and the criminal justice system. A few Black cabinet members can’t undo all of the harm caused in the name of white supremacy, let alone disenfranchise white men.

Elon Musk's outrage after seeing a photo featuring Black cabinet members mirrors his reaction to diverse casting in the film industry. “Shame on Chris Nolan for desecrating Homer,” he said after learning that a Black actress, Lupita Nyong’o, would play Helen of Troy in The Odyssey. Musk condemned the film as a race-swap months before the film’s release and claimed the director “lost his integrity” by casting a Black woman in a role traditionally played by a white actress. Still, the movie earned a whopping $1.816 billion at the global box office, became the highest-grossing R-rated film ever, and earned a 94% approval rating from Rotten Tomatoes. If the casting director decided to capitulate to the outrage of some white men, they would have deprived the audience of an opportunity to judge for themselves.

White men complain about diversity as if it’s some type of Trojan horse, as if Black people have a nefarious plot to sneak in, jump out of the wooden frame, and burn down everything of cultural significance. Yet, it’s racist to assume that Black people would intentionally diminish an artistic project, or that casting a Black actress threatens the integrity of a director. Or that Black people are unfit to serve as cabinet members in the state of Virginia. While conservatives often claim they’re concerned about merit and want the best person to get a position regardless of race, when Black people represent the crème de la crème and are the best fit, they still oppose their inclusion. It’s perplexing, until we consider the most obvious answer: that emphasis on merit is often a thin veil for racism.

Elon Musk, a wealthy white man from South Africa, a nation that subjected Black people to racial oppression under the Apartheid regime, seems to think of diversity in a similar way to Donald Trump, a white man from America, a nation that subjected Black people to chattel slavery, segregation, and discrimination. When speaking to leaders in Ireland last September, Trump claimed, “this country wasn’t built on diversity,” which is ironic given that when European colonizers came to this land, it was inhabited by Indigenous people, and that they brought enslaved Africans here, quite literally creating diversity. Yet, just last year, Trump referred to diversity, equity, and inclusion programs as “discriminatory” at the World Economic Forum.

We cannot fix racial inequality in America and throughout the global community without addressing the white elephant in the room, the privilege afforded to white people. That’s why it’s concerning that some white men seem to shriek in terror at the sight of a Black person in a position of power or even those garnering public attention. Racists want us silent, out of sight, and out of mind, and until the public is more willing to call out this prejudice, this trend will continue. Some white men seem to lose all decorum when confronted with diversity. Rather than catering to their desires by condemning Black people, women, and other marginalized groups to the shadows, society should condemn their prejudice.

Shame on white men who cry foul whenever they don’t see themselves in the limelight, who can’t see the value of including people who have been routinely excluded.Their frustration proves the saying right — “those who’ve become accustomed to privilege see equality as oppression.”We’ve had one Black president and one Black Vice President in 250 years of American history, and no Black woman has ever served as Governor of any state. We’re not living in a nation where white men are being oppressed. On the contrary, this country has consistently shown preferential treatment to white men, and it's high time others share the limelight.